《许森〈尔雅郑玄注稽存〉述评》商榷

Discussion on Review of Erya Zheng Xuan Zhu Jicun By Xu Sen

《图书馆杂志》所刊彭喜双的《许森〈尔雅郑玄注稽存〉述评——兼〈尔雅诂林叙录·郑玄‘尔雅注’(许森辑本)提要辨析》一文中存在诸多值得商榷之处:许森所辑之条数不对;认为许森不区分"《尔雅》郑玄注"与"郑玄本《尔雅》"、多为整合、"袭用"、"分析毫无意义"的观点不正确;认为慧琳《音义》中的材料实无可据太过绝对,主观性太强;对《尔雅诂林叙录·提要》的批评失当,存在一定误读。

There are some doubtful points in Peng Xishuang＇s paper Review ofErya Zheng Xuan Zhu Jicun By Xu Sen which published in the Library Journal： the calculation of the number of Xu Sen＇book was wrong; it was wrong to say that Xu Sen confused Zheng Xuan Ben Erya with Zheng Xuan Zhu Erya, Xu Sen＇s book was plagiarism and Xu＇s analysis is meaningless. It was too subjectivity to affirm the material in Huilin Yinyi is not credible. The criticism ofErya Gulin Xulu was misconduct and misreading.