再论冯子振籍贯--兼与张昌红先生再商榷

Concerning the Birth Place of Feng Zizhen Again:Rediscussion with Mr Zhang Changhong

关于冯子振的籍贯,自古争论不休,其中争论最多的当是攸县说和湘乡说。《冯子振籍贯与生平新证》一文据史料记载及冯子振自己的作品认为其为攸县人,《冯子振籍贯考——兼与易小斌先生商榷》对上文的观点进行了反驳,认为其为湘乡人。细致分析两篇文章的观点和论据,佐以冯子振相关诗文及相关族谱,冯子振为攸县人的证据更为充分。

The debate over the birth place of Feng Zizhen has never stopped since the ancient times,among which Youxian and Xiangxiang represent the two most popular statements.According to the New Evidences of Feng Zizhen＇s Birth Place and Biography,there are historical materials and Feng＇s works indicating that Feng comes from Youxian county.However,an article titled Observation on the Birth Place of Feng Zizhen： A Discussion with Mr.Yi Xiaobin has proposed arguments against the opinion above,regarding Xiangxiang county as his birth place.Based on the analysis of the views and evidences in the two articles while considering relevant poems,essays and genealogical information,it is more convincing that Feng is from Youxian county.