“醉驾入刑”法律效果的实证规范分析——以某市A区法院2015年相关审判案例为样本

An Impirical Normative Analysis of the Legal Effects of Drunk Driving Crimination: A Sample of the Related Trial Cases in 2015 in the Court of District A of a Partiicular City

醉驾入刑以来,在司法实务界和学术界一直存在较大争议。通过采集某法院2015年的相关案例,分析其信度及效度,案件数量及比例,犯罪类型及形态,审判方式、有罪率、上诉率及辩护率和量刑情况,对醉驾行为的成罪标准及罪状适用,醉驾的判断标准,法定刑的合理配置,判决的公正与效率提出实践性建议。

There have been great disputes between judicature circles and academic community since drunk driving crimination. In light of collection of the related trial cases in 2015 in the court A, analysis of their reliability and validity, the caseload and proportion, crime types and forms, trial modes, culpability rate, appeal rates, defense rates and sentencing, practical suggestions are presented on drunk driving in terms of crimination norms and application of accusation, identification norms for drunk driving, rational allocation of statutory sentence, verdict justice and efficiency.