对不能犯理论中客观危险说的探究——基于《刑事审判参考》第208号案例的分析

The Analysis of Objective Danger Theory in Impossibility Theory:Based on NO.208th Case in“Criminal Trial Reference”

《刑事审判参考》(总第28辑)公布的第208号苏某贩卖毒品案例存在主观归罪、罪刑失衡、滥用特情侦查等问题,本案可以运用不能犯的理论加以分析。通过阐述不能犯领域中的四种学说,重点分析客观危险说的合理性,总结客观危险说对毒品犯罪案件的现实意义,运用客观危险说深入分析贩卖毒品罪的构成要件,对本案是否构成贩卖毒品罪及其可罚性进行分析,可以得出本案被告人无罪的结论。

Since the famous German scholar Feuerbach first proposed,has always been one of the focus of controversy in the field of criminal law theory,a correct understanding of the meaning can not be committed to help us clarify the criminal law position,a deep understanding of the inherent criminal law spirit.In this paper,the real case as the starting point,first of all briefly put forward the case of Su Yongqing drug trafficking case of doubt;then elaborated can not commit the field of the four main theories,focusing on the objective risk theory of rationality,summed up the objective risk theory The practical significance of the case of drug-related crimes;Finally,the application of objective hazards that in-depth analysis of the substance of the crime of drug trafficking,the case of punishability and risk judgments,resulting in a new conclusion.