科技期刊论文质量评价方法及相关研究

Research Advance on Quality Evaluation of Papers in Sci-tech Periodicals

科研论文的质量评价是对研究人员科研水准的衡量,也是作为信息载体的科技期刊学术质量的重要保证。建立一套客观性强、准确性高、标准化作用明显的科技期刊论文质量评价方法对于强化论文选取机制有着极为重要的意义。本研究立足于编审层次,以流程中各节点作为切入,在综述现有评价方法的基础上,着重探讨刊前定量评价的方法及意义,并对进一步优化方法学构建提出了建议,以期为期刊管理与评价人员提供参考。

The quality evaluation of scientific research paper is the measure of research level for researchers. Moreover, it is also important to the academic quality guarantee for sci-tech periodicals, which acts as a kind of information carrier. Thus, it is very important to establish an evaluation system for the quality of research papers with strong objectivity and high accuracy in order to optimize the mechanism of paper selection. From the point of redactology, this paper discussed the existing methods for paper evaluation in review, with emphasis on the method of quantitative evaluation before publishing particularly. Suggestionsof methodological optimization were also mentioned in this article which could be a reference for other managers of periodicals.