“互联网专条”存废之争与规范模式的思考

Thinking on the Necessity of Adding the Internet Clause and its Legislative Pattern

2017年11月4日,全国人大法工委公布《中华人民共和国反不正当竞争法(修订草案)》(文中称《修订草案》)二次审议稿(以下简称二次审议稿),笔者注意到,此前引发理论界与实务界较大争议的"互联网专条"(1)在二次审议稿中得到了保留并进行了相应调整。就二次审议稿该条款的现行规定,结合基层审判经验,笔者认为互联网专条应当保留,并提出互联网专条立法应清楚地界定调整范围,且宜采用"要素式"规范模式(2)的设想。

Recently, the 2rd draft revision of the Unfair Competition Law was published by the National People＇ s Congress Standing Committee. It is noted that one of the most contentious clause - - the Internet Clause was remained and revised resonably. Based on its current content, as well as several years＇ judicial experience, the authors agree to contain this particular provision for banning malicious acticities on the internet. Also we consider the legislation should more clearly define its regulating scope and adopt the Factor- mixed pattern.