我国反垄断法规制最惠待遇协议的法理分析被引量：2

Analysis on Regulation of Most-favored Treatment of Antitrust Law in China

下载PDF

导出

摘要最惠待遇协议因可能对竞争产生重大影响而成为了反垄断法的关注热点。本文在界定"最惠待遇协议"概念的基础上,分析了其可能促进竞争和抑制竞争的双重效果,通过借鉴美国和欧盟两个法域运用反垄断法对最惠待遇协议进行规制的经验,提出了我国应以"合理原则"为基础对其进行规制的总体思路,并结合我国反垄断法的立法和实践,就规制最惠待遇协议的具体分析框架和相关配套制度提出了建议及改进意见。 Most-favored treatment agreement has been concerned by antitrust law recently because of its substantial infuence on the competition. Based on the defnition of the ＂most-favored treatment agreement＂,this article analyzes the double effects of the agreement on promoting the competition and restricting the competition. Referring to the experience of the regulation of the agreement by antitrust law in the US and in EU, this article takes the position China should regulate this kind of agreement by the general guide of ＂rule of reason＂. And considering the legislation and implement of the antitrust law in China, this article puts forward some viewpoints and suggestions on designing the concrete framework of analysis and some supporting systems.

作者董灵张寒

机构地区对外经济贸易大学法学院北京尚伦律师事务所

出处《竞争政策研究》 2017年第1期35-43,共9页 Competition Policy Research

关键词最惠待遇协议合理原则最惠国待遇反垄断法规制 most-favored treatment rule of reason MFN regulation of antitrust law

分类号 D922.294 [政治法律—经济法学]

引文网络
相关文献

参考文献1

1黄勇,田辰.网络分销模式中最惠国待遇条款的反垄断法分析[J].法律适用,2014(9):49-53. 被引量：9

二级参考文献12

1Anthony J. Dennis, Most favored nation contract clauses under the antitrust law, University of Dayton Law Review, 821, P.1(1995).
2Reazin v. Blue Cross & Blue Shield, 663 P. Supp. 1360, 899 lZ.2d 951 (10th Cir.).
3U.S.V. Delta Dental oftk.I., 943 F. Supp. 172(D.R..I. 1996).
4Jeffrey L. Kessler, Aldo A. Badini, Susannah P. Torpey, Federal Court Ruling Calls Most-Favored-Nation Clauses into Question by Deeming Ap- ple's Use of MFNs a Per Se Unlawful Violation of the Antitrust Laws, available at http://www.winston.com/en/thought-leadership/federal-court-naling- calls-most-favored-nation-clauses-into-question-by-deeming.html.
5Survey of Morgan Stanley: Booking.com is thrashing Expedia in Europe, data of July, 2013.
6OFT press release 65 / 12 of 31 July 2012, available at http://www.o.gov.uk/news-and-updates/press/2012/65 - 12.
7The Office of Fair Trading, Hotel online booking:Decision to accept commitments to remove certain discounting restrictions for Online Travel A- gents.
8Online platforms - who can set the price and are most favored nation clauses compatible with competition rules,2014(1),P. 2.
9IoarmisKokkoris,Expedia and Booking.corn: Agent or Distributor, Competition Policy International, 2012, P.1-2.
10Evan D. Brewer, The e-book price fixing litigation: curious outlier or harbinger of change in antitrust enforcement policy? Hasting Science and Technology Law Journal, Vol. 6:1 Winter 2014, P.5.