对传统目录学的反思与建构——《中国古代目录学研究》读后

Reflection and Construction of Traditional Bibliography——After Reading Study of Ancient Chinese Bibliography

从"宏观建构,理论言说"的著述理念、"结构谨严,定位准确"的学术理性、"史论结合,真知灼见"的论证方式等三个方面分析评述傅荣贤教授《中国古代目录学研究》一书的突出优点。该书在摆脱传统观念束缚的基础上,审察中西目录学之异同,继而揭示出我国古代目录学的核心价值,建构起较为完善的古代目录学理论,并指明了中西目录学有机结合的发展方向。但该书对中西目录学有机结合的具体操作论述稍显不足。

It analyzes the outstanding merits of the Professor Fu Rongxian＇s Study of Ancient Chinese Bibliogra- phy from three aspects： the writing idea of macro construction and theoretical discourse, the academic rationality of tight framework and accurate positioning and the argumentation way of combining history with theo- ry. The book gets rid of the traditional concept, judges the differences between Chinese and Western bibliogra- phy, and then reveals the core value of ancient Chinese bibliography, constructs the ancient bibliography theory and puts forward the development direction of the organic combination of Chinese and Western bibliography. But the discussion of how to operate the organic combination of Chinese and Western bibliography is insufficient. 7 refs.