基于映射方法对比的受控词表互操作质量影响因素研究

Research on Influencing Factors of the Quality of Controlled Vocabularies Interoperability Based on Comparisons among Mapping Methods

[目的/意义]通过对现有映射方法的归纳总结及对比,分析不同映射方法对映射质量的影响,以期对未来不同受控词表之间实现高质量的互操作提供参考。[方法/过程]文章采用归纳总结与对比分析的方法,对映射方法进行总结并分析其对受控词表映射质量的影响。[结果/结论]映射方法包括词表连接模型及概念映射方法,不同的词表连接模型具有不同的映射条件、映射程度、映射工作量及映射质量,概念映射方法的映射类型、映射方向、映射数量的选择也会影响映射质量。[局限]未将分析结果应用于映射实践。

[ Purpose/significance ] Based on the summary and comparison of existed mapping methods, this paper analyzes how the methods affect mapping quality, in order to help improving interoperability quality among different controlled vocabularies in the future. [ Method/process ] Induction and conclusion method and comparative analysis method are adopted in this paper to make summary of existed mapping methods and their influence on the mapping quality of controlled vocabularies. [ Result/conclu- sion ] Mapping methods include vocabulary connecting models and concept mapping methods. Different vocabulary connecting models have different mapping conditions, degrees, workload and quality. And the selection of mapping types, mapping directions, map- ping quantities of concept mapping methods can also affect mapping quality. [ Limitations] The analysis results are not applied to the mapping practice.