聚众斗殴转化犯定性的合理性探究

The Rational Research about Affray Transformation Crime's Quality

关于聚众斗殴致人重伤、死亡的定性,一直存在较大争议,特别是近年来全国统一司法考试关于此问题法律拟制的定性,更是引起了学者们关于聚众斗殴转化犯是法律拟制还是注意规定的争论。分析争议的最终落脚点在于符合司法实践中法益保护和罪刑均衡的需要,因此,应当跳出非此即彼的惯性思维模式,以合理性为基准点寻求新的解决方案。

The qualitative problems causing serious injury or death in affray has been controversial, especially in recent years, the national unified judicial examination argued it is a legal fiction, which has been causing the scholars debate on the affray crime＇s essence that is a legal fiction or a notice. The ultimate base of the problem is conforming the needs of legal protection and balance of crime and punishment in judicial practice. Therefore, we should jump out of the inertial thinking mode and take the rationality as a based noint to seek for new solutions.