对威廉姆森反透明性系列论证的质疑

Objections of Williamson's Anti-luminosity Series of Arguments

在简要介绍威廉姆森反透明性系列论证的基础上,对其论证的过程进行细致的剖析,发现他的反透明性论证和反KK原则论证统一于他的"容错边界"理论。然后通过"廓清认知途径"的方法来否证他的反KK论证,通过对"容错边界"的质疑来质疑他的反透明性论证,最后指出:无论在威廉姆森的知识概念上,还是他的反透明性系列论证的过程中,都存在双重标准的问题。

This paper was based on a brief introduction to Williamson＇s Anti-luminosity series of arguments,and a detailed analysis was made of his demonstration process. It had found that Williamson＇s Anti-luminosity arguments and Anti-KK principle argumentation were unified in his ＂ margin for error＂ theory. Then,disproving his Anti-KK demonstration by ＂ clearing cognitive approach＂ and disproving his Anti-KK principle argument by negating his ＂ margin for error＂ theory. The paper finally pointed out that neither Williamson＇s concept of knowledge nor his Anti-luminosity series of arguments,there were double standard problem.