摘要
张春帆的《政海》和包天笑的《甲子絮谭》从不同侧面描绘了直皖战争。《政海》描述了第一次直皖战争,《甲子絮谭》描述了第二次直皖战争;《政海》重点描绘了几个主要人物的个性,《甲子絮谭》则全景式地反映了江浙齐卢大战。在反映扰民害民方面,《甲子絮谭》远胜于《政海》;而描写正面交锋,《政海》则高于《甲子絮谭》。《甲子絮谭》的重点在于强调战争的残酷性。此外,1924—1925年间,俞天愤、严独鹤、程瞻庐、范烟桥、顾明道、江红蕉等人,也都以江浙大战为题材,写过相关的短篇小说。
Zheng Hai by Zhang Chunfan and Jiazi Stories by Bao Tianxiao describe from various aspects the Zhi-Wan War. Zheng Hai describes the 1st Zhi-Wan War, while Jiazi Stories covers the 2nd Zhi-Wan War. Zheng Hai focuses on portraying several key personalities, while Jiazi Stories gives panoramic descriptions of the Jiang-Zhe-Qi-Lu Battle. Jiazi Stories does far better than Zheng Hai in depicting the harassment and disasters brought about by war, while Zheng Hai excels Jiazi Stories when it comes to direct confrontations. Jiazi Stories focuses on highlighting the cruelty of war. In addition, writers such as Yu Tianfen, Yan Duhe, Cheng Zhanlu, Fan Yanqiao, Gu Mingdao and Jiang Hongjiao also wrote short stories by drawing on the theme of the Jiang-Zhe Battle.
作者
范伯群
FAN Boqun(School of Humanity,Soochow University,Suzhou 215123,China)
出处
《苏州教育学院学报》
2018年第4期2-13,共12页
Journal of Suzhou College of Education
基金
国家社科基金重大项目(13&ZD120)
