南海仲裁案仲裁庭处理《联合国海洋法公约》与一般国际法关系问题探析被引量：3

下载PDF

导出

摘要在南海仲裁案中,仲裁庭处理《联合国海洋法公约》(以下简称《公约》)与包括习惯国际法在内的一般国际法关系失当,将本应由一般国际法调整与规范的权利义务事项诉诸《公约》。《公约》没有完全涵盖与穷尽与海洋有关的一切事项,其对于具有表现形式多样的历史性权利问题和受各种因素影响显著的大陆国家远洋群岛问题并没有予以充分考虑。《公约》与包括习惯国际法在内的一般国际法是并行的法律体系,无论是从弥补《公约》自身缺陷、满足国际社会现实需要而言,还是从维护国际海洋秩序、推动国际海洋法向前发展而言,都不应无视包括习惯国际法在内的一般国际法在调整和规范《公约》未尽权利义务事项上的价值和作用。

作者丁铎

机构地区中国南海研究院

出处《南海法学》 2017年第4期100-111,共12页 The South China Sea Law Journal

基金国家社科基金青年项目"‘21世纪海上丝绸之路’建设与南海问题交互影响机制研究"(17CGJ025)

关键词《联合国海洋法公约》习惯国际法历史性权利远洋群岛南海仲裁案

分类号 D993.5 [政治法律—国际法学]

引文网络
相关文献

参考文献3

1谈中正.“历史性权源”在《联合国海洋法公约》中的法律地位:兼评南海仲裁案中菲律宾的相关主张[J].国际法研究,2016(3):3-22. 被引量：3
2马新民.“南海仲裁案”裁决缘何非法无效[J].中国法学,2016(5):29-36. 被引量：5
3雷筱璐.历史性权利对《海洋法公约》相关制度和规则的促进作用[J].湖北大学学报（哲学社会科学版）,2014,41(3):70-74. 被引量：6

二级参考文献13

1Robert Beckman.China,UNCLOS and the South China Sea[Z].Asian Society of International Law Third Biennial Conference,Beijing,China, 27-28 August 2011.
2The Department of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of the Philippines. Notification and Statement of Claim[EB/OL].http ://www.dfa.gov.ph/ index.php/newsroom/dfa-reeases/73-statement-by-secretary-of-foreign-affairs-albert-de-rsari-n-the-uncs-arbitral-proceedings- against-china-to-achieve-a-peaceful-and-durable- solution-to-the-dispute-in-the-wps, 2013-01-23.
3International Law Commission.Regime of the Territorial Sea,Comments by Governments on the Draft Provisional Articles Concerning the Regime of Territorial Sea Adopted by the International Law Commission at its Sixth Session(A/CN.4/90 and Add.l-6)[A]//In Yearbook of the International Law Commission 1955[R].New York:United Nation Publications, 1955,2.
4United Nations Conference on the Law of the Sea.Official Records:summary records of the first committe[R].New York:United Nations Publications, 1958,3.
5J. P. A. Francois.Regime of the Territorial Sea:Amendments Proposed by Special Rapporteur on Basis of Governments Observations on the Draft Provisional Articles Adopted at the Sixth Session the International Law Commission(A/CN.4/93 )[A]//In Yearbook of the International Law Commission[R].New York:United Nation Publications, 1955,2.
6Andrea Gioia.Bays and Gulfs[J].Rudiger Wolfrum.The Max Planck Encyclopedia of Public International Law[DB/OL].www.mpepil.com, 2012- 09-20.
7Geoge N.Barrie. Historical Bays[J].Comparative International Law Journal of Southern Africa, 1973, (6).
8United States Department of State Bureau of Oceans and International Environmental and Scientific Affairs.Limits in the Sea No.1l2:Straight Baseline, Philippines[R].Washington DC : United States Department of State, 1992,82.
9Third United Nations Conference on the Law of the Sea.Official Records of the Third United Nations Conference on the Law of the Sea: Summary Records of Meeting of the First, Second and Third Committees[Z].New York:United Nations Publications, 1974,3.
10Gidel.Le Droit International Public de la mer:Vol.3[M].les 6tablissements Mellott6e, 1934.