对《针灸学》教材中几处内容的商榷

Doubts about some contents of textbook Acupuncture and Moxibustion

《针灸学》(人民卫生出版社第3版)教材于2016年6月出版发行,笔者谨就教学过程中发现的几处问题进行了探讨。本文既对世界卫生组织(WHO)针灸适应证等信息的准确性进行了探讨,也对腧穴定位方法描述、风市和脑户的定位、针具器械及施针部位消毒、毫针规格与捻转角度、头针定位与主治以及针灸治疗病种选择和证型等内容的正确性提出了质疑,并提出了教材编写应以国家及行业标准为依据的建议。

The textbook Acupuncture and Moxibustion（PMPH 3 rd edition） was published in June 2016. The paper discussed several doubts in the textbook which were found during teaching. They involved the accuracy of information regarding WHO-recommended acupuncture indications and the correctness of some contents such as acupoint locating methods, locations of Fengshi（GB 31） and Naohu（GV 17）, disinfection of needles and skin, specification of acupuncture needles, rotating angle of needle manipulation, locations and indications of scalp acupuncture line, and selection and pattern classification of acupuncture-suitable diseases. Besides, the paper advocated that national or industry standards should be followed and adopted while compiling the textbooks.