科技论文作者申诉的编辑处理策略

Editing strategy on the author's appeals

近年来随着论文产出量的上升,退稿率和申诉率也同步增长。如何降低申诉率,提高期刊的品牌效应,文章归纳总结了导致申诉发生的几种主客观因素,提出了遴选最佳审稿人、强化对审稿意见的甄别和再加工、协助专家提高审稿质量、加强与审稿人的沟通、强化服务作者意识、健全申诉机制等应对策略。此外,还介绍了《暴雨灾害》历年申诉现状及国外知名期刊的申诉机制。

In recent years,the rejection rate and author＇s appeals rate are increasing with the rising of paper＇s output. How to reduce the appeals rate and improve the brand effect of journals？ This paper summarized several objective and subjective factors that may lead to appeals. Several countermeasures are put forward： selecting best peer reviewers,strengthening the selection and reprocessing on expert＇s comments on papers,helping to improve the quality of the review, strengthening communication with reviewers, enhancing service awareness to author,and improving the author＇s appeals mechanism. In addition,this paper also introduces the appealing status of the Torrental Rain and Disasters in the past years and the appealing mechanism of famous foreign journals.