诉判同一视角下行政案件裁判方式的反思与完善

Rethink and Improve the Adjudication Methods for Administrative Cases

长期以来,我国行政诉讼中存在简单判决类型无法满足诉判同一的审判需求,一定数量的诉判非一致性判决客观存在的现状。在分析影响行政裁判诉判关系理论因素的基础上,从诉判同一在当前行政裁判方式中的体现出发,建议在诉判非一致性判决的规范适用、各类裁判方式之间的区别适用、各种新类型判决方式的探寻适用等方面完善行政案件裁判方式。

The problem of making material changes to the plaintiff＇s claim by the court adjudication has long existed in the trial of certain simple administrative cases in China. On the basis of analyzing the theoretical factors affecting the relationship between the plaintiff＇s claim and the court judgment and examining the terminated administrative cases where the claim and court ruling are consistent, the adjudicating methods for administrative lawsuits can be improved in terms of the normative application of adjudicating consistently with the plaintiff＇s claim, the differentiated application of the various adjudicating modes, and the application of new types of adjudicating methods on an explorative basis.