“诉讼诈骗”批判

The Comments on the Lawsuit Defraud

"诉讼诈骗"指向的法律现象或问题是客观存在的,但以"诉讼诈骗"对之进行理论概括和阐释却是极不科学的。为了还原事物的本来面目和矫正错误的认识,必须摒弃"诉讼诈骗"的概念或提法。在法学研究和司法实践中,宜以恶意诉讼或诉讼欺诈取代之。"诉讼诈骗"或诉讼欺诈行为之所以不能视为诈骗犯罪,是因为"诉讼诈骗"根本不符合诈骗犯罪立法的基本精神和诈骗犯罪构成的一般原理,肯定"诉讼诈骗"还会形成法律悖论。"诉讼诈骗"不是三角诈骗,它与三角诈骗行为具有本质的区别。

Lawsuit Defraud is not a scientific notion in criminal law and should not be accepted.Lawsuit Defraud is not a crime of defraud, because it does not conform to legislation spirit and will produce a wrong conclusion.Lawsuit Defraud is different from the a triangle defraud and not belong to a triangle defraud.