2009—2013年《包装学报》零被引论文分析

An Analysis of Non-Cited Articles in Packaging Journal Between 2009 and 2013

以中国知网全文数据库为统计源,对2009—2013年《包装学报》零被引论文进行统计分析。2009—2013年,学报共刊载论文37 0篇,其中,截至数据统计日期,零被引论文共51篇,零被引率为13.78%。51篇零被引论文中,英文论文为1篇,占1.96%;在主题方面,"包装文化与教育""艺术与设计"主题的零被引论文占比较大;与期刊载文平均篇幅相比较,零被引论文的平均篇幅要稍短于同期载文平均篇幅;讲师及以下、硕士研究生的零被引论文所占比例较大,分别为35.29%和33.33%;合著规模为2人的论文,其零被引率超过该合著区间的总载文率;零被引论文的篇均文献数大多低于总载文的篇均文献数。基于此统计分析,建议学报尽量减少或避免刊登英文文章、与包装关联度不高的"艺术与设计"类文章、论述空泛而学术价值不高的理论性文章、学术质量不高的职称论文和硕士研究生论文,适当提高刊载论文的合著规模,增加论文的参考文献数量,刊载篇幅较长的论文。

Based on the full-text database of CNKI,a statistical analysis has been made of non-cited articles in Packaging Journal from2009-2013.A total of370articles has been published in the journal from2009to2013,among which,up to the date of statistics,as many as51articles have never been a source of citation,with a zero citation rate of the journal as high as13.78%.There is only one English article among all the51non-cited ones,accounting for1.96%of the total.As for the theme of articles,those related to“packaging culture and education”and“art and design”occupy a relatively larger proportion in zero citation.Compared with the average length of the journal articles during the same period,the average length of the non-cited articles is slightly smaller than the average length of all the articles.In terms of authors of the non-cited articles,lecturers with a master,s degree or below account for a large proportion of35.29%and33.33%,respectively.Among them,the zero citation rate of articles of co-authors of two exceeds the total publication rate.The number of non-cited articles is much smaller than that of the total articles.Based on the statistical analysis,it is suggested that an effort should be made to minimize or avoid the publication of English articles,articles with such lowly-correlative themes as“art and design”,highly theoretical articles with vague and general argumentation or with little academic value,and professional theses or graduate papers of poor quality.Meanwhile it is advisable to expand the scale of published papers,increase the number of references and the length of articles as well.