学位授权点专项评估指标体系的效度研究——以法律硕士专项评估为例

On the Validity of the Specific Evaluation Indicator System on the Units Authorized to Confer Academic Degrees——With the Special Evaluation on Juris Masters as an example

学位授权点专项评估指标体系的效度决定了专项评估制度能否发挥对学位与研究生质量的监督作用。以法律硕士专项评估指标体系为研究对象,以自我评估报告为研究基础,分析专项评估指标体系中师资队伍、人才培养、质量保证等指标的效度。通过对专项评估指标体系一级指标权重、二级重点指标设置、二级指标和测评点分布、评测点得分标准、配套表格和材料的分析,发现我国法律硕士专项评估指标体系基本上能够全面反映法律硕士学位点的建设状况,但也存在一些问题。

The validity of the specific indicator system for qualification evaluation on the authorized degree-conferring unit determines whether the system can play the role of supervising the quality of academic degree holders and postgraduates.Based on the evaluation reports on juris masters,this paper takes the specific indicator system for qualification evaluation as the research object and analyzes the validity of the indicators for teaching staff,student training and quality assurance.Through the analysis of the weights of the first-level indicators,the settings of the second-level indicators,the distribution of the second-level indicators and the evaluation points,the scoring criteria of the evaluation points,the attached forms to the system and relevant materials,this paper concludes that the specific indicator system can effectively reflect the status quo of the units authorized to confer juris master degrees,yet,there are still some existing problems.