《述古堂书目》版本考

The Edition Study of Shu Gu Tang Bibliography

《述古堂书目》是清初钱曾所编撰的藏书目录,虽不及其《读书敏求记》更为后世所关注,但学术价值同样不容忽视。国家图书馆现藏清初述古堂钞本《述古堂书目》,为傅增湘旧藏,学界一般认为该本为钱氏手定初稿本。然而,通过将其与其他几种钞本在分卷、前后序等方面进行比较,分析《述古堂书目》最初的特点,由此指出国家图书馆所藏述古堂钞本实非初稿本,只是其中的一个修订本。同时,通过对这些版本的梳理,也体现出钞本文献在流传过程中与刻本不同的特点。

Shugutang Bibliography is a collection of books compiled by Qian Zeng in the early Qing dynasty.Although it is not more concerned by later generations than Du Shu Min Qiu Ji,its academic value cannot be ignored.The National Library is now holding a copy of Shugutang Bibliography,shugutang banknote,which is fu Zengxiang’s old collection.The paper analyses the initial characteristics of Shugutang Bibliography by comparing it with several other reserves from the aspects of volume classification,foreword and epilogue.It is pointed out that the handwritten copy of Shugutang Bibliography is not the first draft,but one of the revised edition.At the same time,the paper presents the different characteristics of handwritten documents from block-printed edition in the spreading process through sorting out these versions.