竞合论与罪数论的反思与建构

Reflection and Renovation on the Competing Theory and Crime Quantity Theory

目前我国刑法学界对竞合论与罪数论的观点不一,竞合论与罪数论并非天壤之别,二者只是路径不一,功能、效果、本质相同,没有必要全部推翻现行的罪数论,简单移植德国竞合论。立足于罪数论的我国犯罪竞合理论之构建应该是确定研究的对象,确立罪数的处断规则,并合理构建内部体系。

In current Chinese criminal law circle,arguments continue between the competing theory and crime quantity theory,which are not contradictory but consistent in functions,effects and essence,though express in different pathway.It is unnecessary to overturn all the current crime quantity theory and transplant German competing theory.For crime quantity-based Chinese criminal law,the construction of competing theory should identify the subject of study,set up determination rules of crime quantity and construct rational interior system.