摘要
以学术书评为分析样本的学术授信评价是对档案学经典著作的整体性评价,其评价指标Z指数可作为档案学经典著作评价体系的重要组成部分。本文依据图书Z指数的计算方法,选取《档案学经典著作》丛书中的部分著作,以学术书评为计算对象,得出了它们的Z指数并进行了比较分析,为档案学经典著作的评价提供了一种新的视角和方法。该评价方法虽然存在一定缺陷,但是随着经典阅读和相关研究的深入开展,其未来会有较大的发展空间。
Academic credit evaluation, which takes academic book review as an analysis sample, is a holistic evaluation of archival classic books. Its evaluation index Z' index can be used as an important part of the archival classic evalu.ition system. Based on the calculation method of the book Z index, this paper selects some of the books from the series of "Archival Classics Books", taking academic book reviews as the evaluated object, then their Z' index is obtained and a comparative analysis is conducted. This provides a new perspective and method for the evaluation of archival classic books. Although this evaluation method has certain defects, with the deep development of classics reading and related research, there will be much more room for development in the fiiture.
作者
邢变变
各玉杰
XING Bianbian;GE Yujie(School of Information Management, Zhengzhou University, Zhengzhou 450001;School of Information Management Archives Profrssional and Academic Evaluation Center, Zhengzhou University, Zhengzhou 450001)
出处
《档案学研究》
CSSCI
北大核心
2019年第3期83-88,共6页
Archives Science Study
基金
国家社会科学基金重点项目“档案学经典著作评价研究”(项目编号:17ATQ011)
关键词
档案学经典著作
学术授信
学术书评
Z'指数
archival classic books
academic credit
academic book review
Z' index
