刑事诉讼法学研究的中国图景:1949—2019——基于“法学三大刊”论文的分析

Chinese prospect of science criminal procedure law research:1949—2019 analysis based on papers in “Three Major Periodicals of Law”

自中华人民共和国成立以来,我国的刑事诉讼法学已然走过70年。在过去70年里,我国的刑事诉讼法学经历了艰难探索期、恢复重建期、蓬勃发展期和纵深发展期4个阶段。以“法学三大刊”自1949年以来发表的刑事诉讼法学论文为对象的考察发现,我国刑事诉讼法学研究呈现出学术规范从失范粗糙到精细严谨、学术对话从各说各话到良性互动、研究范式从文本注释到回归实践、研究进路从以英美为师到中国道路的动态图景,但也存在研究方法的多元化不足、“实践导向偏弱”、研究视野较为局促、研究内容的原创性不够等问题。

Since the founding of the People’s Republic of China,China’s criminal procedure law has passed 70 years.In the past 70 years,China’s criminal procedure law has experienced four stages:difficult exploration period,recovery and reconstruction period,vigorous development and in-depth development period.Taking the criminal procedure law papers published by the three major journals of law since 1949 as the object of investigation,it is found that the research on criminal procedure law in our country shows a dynamic picture of academic norms from anomie roughness to fine preciseness,academic dialogue from each statement to benign interaction,research paradigm from text annotation to practice return,research approach from Britain and America to China,but there are also problems such as insufficient diversification of research methods,“weak practice orientation”,relatively short research vision,and research content lack of originality.