“平安海区”建设评价指标体系研究——以浙江省为例

Study on the evaluation index system of “the Safety Sea” construction——a case study by taking Zhejiang Province as the typical sample

为推进"平安海区"建设,客观评价"平安海区"的建设成效及相关措施的落实情况,促进软、硬件资源配置优化,引导和推动"平安海区"建设深入可持续发展,构建"平安海区"建设评价指标体系。以浙江省为例,通过调研相关部门、专家函询及会议咨询,按照指标体系选取的基本原则,对选取指标进行了多次优化调整,运用德尔菲法(DM)和层次分析法(AHP)构建的评价指标体系包含三个层次,其中,一级指标3个,分别为否决指标、定性指标和定量指标;二级指标12个;三级指标26个。根据专家评价尺度表取均值建立各级元素的标定值矩阵,得出同级指标的相对重要度,经一致性检验后确定各指标的权重系数。经专家咨询、试用评判,结果表明:构建的指标体系能较为全面、客观地反映浙江"平安海区"的建设成效,凸显出后期建设需关注的重点,与经验评价结果较为一致,验证了提出的评价指标体系的科学性及可行性,可为"平安海区"建设评价指标体系的推广提供参考。

This paper is aimed at constructing an evaluation index system which is conducive to assessing the construction effectiveness of"the Safety Sea"and the implementation of the relevant measures,so as to promote the construction of the environment of"the Safety Sea". Meanwhile it is useful to optimize the allocation of the software and hardware resources and guide its construction in the sustainable development environment. Taking the construction of "the Safety Sea"in Zhejiang as a sampling case through extensive investigation in the relevant aspects and questionnaire surveys from the experts according to the basic principles of selection of indicator system,the chosen indicators have been optimized and adjusted for a few times. The evaluation index system has been set up with Delphi method(DM) and Analytic Hierarchy Process(AHP) consisting of 3 levels with 3 1-st-class indicators covering the veto index,qualitative index and quantitative index,12 2-nd-class and 26 3-rd-class indicators.The matrix of the calibration values for each level of elements has also been proposed based on the average expertise indexes. And then,the same level indicators of the relative importance have been gained whereas the weight coefficients of each indicator have been certified and confirmed through the consistency test.All the aforementioned results help us to verify that the index system can truthfully reflect the construction effectiveness of"the Safety Sea"in Zhejiang comprehensively and objectively,which is qualified enough to highlight the essential points needed to pay attention to. Moreover,the above gained results turn out to be basically consistent with the empirical assessment results of the relevant experts and departments. Hence,the evaluation index system should be qualified enough to provide needed reference to promote the evaluation index system of "the Safety Sea"construction.