人工智能生成物不具有作品属性的分析

Analysis of Artificial Intelligence Products without Works Attribute

人工智能生成物是否属于著作权法意义上的作品,应根据生成物的产生过程判断,而不仅仅是生成物外在本身。现有人工智能只能按照人类预先设定好的特定算法、程序或规则生成内容,生成物是执行既定流程的产物,不符合著作权法中作品独创性要求,不宜认定为作品。即使不考虑生成物的创作主体,认为其具有外在作品的一般属性而享有著作权,同样会带来权利归属的难题。

whether artificial intelligence products belong to works in the sense of copyright law should be judged according to the production process of products,not only the external products themselves.The existing artificial intelligence can only generate content according to the specific algorithm,program or rule set in advance by human beings.The product is the product of the implementation of the established process,which does not meet the requirements of the originality of works in the copyright law and should not be recognized as works.Even if we do not consider the creation subject of the product and think that it has the general attribute of the external works and enjoys the copyright,it will also bring the problem of the ownership of the right.