不认罪案件中适用独立量刑程序的理论分析--基于新司法改革背景

Application of Independent Sentencing Procedure in Cases of No Pleading guilty under the Background of New Judicial Reform

我国当前实行的是相对独立的量刑程序模式,尽管该模式在被告人认罪案件中具有可行性,但在不认罪案件中却存在着较多的局限性,独立的量刑程序模式则可有效避免现有模式的弊端。独立的量刑程序更符合定罪与量刑之间的差异性要求,也更有利于实现程序价值和落实庭审实质化。此外,在案件繁简分流、认罪认罚从宽等新的司法改革背景下,不认罪案件中适用独立的量刑程序已经逐步具备了可行性。

A relatively independent model of sentencing procedures is implemented in China currently. Although the model is feasible in the case of defendant plead guilty, there are still many limitations in the case of no pleading guilty.The independent sentencing procedure model can effectively avoid the existing drawbacks, which is more in line with the differential requirement between conviction and sentencing, and is more conducive to realizing the procedure value and implementing the substantive trial. In addition, in the context of new judicial reforms such as simplification of cases, confession and punishment, the application of independent sentencing procedures in the case of no pleading guilty has gradually become feasible.