复印报刊资料《成人教育学刊》研究的方法论反思

Rethinking of the Methodologies in Renmin University’s Copy Edition of the Materials from Periodicals for Reference of Journal of Adult Education Research

近年来,学界逐渐兴起以人大复印报刊资料转载论文为研究对象的热潮。研究基于《成人教育学刊》转载文献研究成果的研究现状:元研究理念的萌芽与勃发,载文基本数据的多维挖掘,研究方法反思的逐渐兴起;发现该类研究还存在诸多瓶颈问题:研究者对教育研究方法论核心内涵的理解缺失,外在数据信息与内在价值意义的割裂,学术研究趋势预测的内容相悖或简单重复;提出实现范式转换的必要准备的三点建议:成人教育研究方法论的重新审视,从文献计量走向内容分析,从文本解读迈进话语分析。

Papers on the Renmin University’s Copy Edition of the Materials from Periodicals for Reference of Journal of Adult Education represent frontier trends.From the research of the reprinted papers,we may get some information:Meta study has become a new trend.Many researchers pay more attention on data mining in multiple dimensions.However,there are still many problems:the understanding and description of methodologies is still unclear.Comprehension about values is not from view of the essence of data.The contents of the prediction of academic research trends are inconsistent or simply repeated.It’s necessary to transform the traditional study paradigms to a new one.What should we do in the future?Firstly,We needs to review and rethink the methodologies.Secondly,focus on content analysis rather than bibliometric analysis.Thirdly,Pay more attention to discourse analysis.