学术论文错误信息传播初探——以冲击地压矿井数量为例

Preliminary Study on the Spread of Misinformation in Academic Papers:Case Study of the Number of Coal Burst Mines

[目的/意义]探究学术论文中的错误信息传播有助于改进学术信息的质量。[方法/过程]以冲击地压矿井数量为观测点,通过文献调研、文献统计分析法,研究错误信息的传播时序,探讨期刊档次、作者数量和层次、研究群体、参考文献等对错误信息的影响,并对如何避免学术论文错误信息传播进行反思。[结果/结论]期刊档次、作者身份、作者数量对错误信息的产生并无显著性差异,错误信息特别集中在某一研究群体的现象并不明显,参考文献引用的准确与否对错误信息的产生具有重要影响。避免学术论文错误信息传播方面,可以从论文作者、期刊编辑、论文发表后的再次更正、推进行业信息共享、改进编审流程等方面着手。

[Purpose/significance]Exploring the dissemination of misinformation in academic papers will help improve the quality of academic papers.[Method/process]The paper takes the number of coal burst mines as the observation point studies on the dissemination time sequence of misinformation explores the impact of journal levels the number of authors and levels the research groups and references on misinformation by using literature research and literature statistical analysis methods.Also the paper reflects on avoiding the dissemination of misinformation about academic papers.[Result/conclusion]There is no significant difference in the generation of misinformation by journal levels author identity and number of authors.It is not obvious that the misinformation is concentrated in a particular research group.The accuracy of the references has an important impact on the generation of misinformation.The aspects of the paper authors journal editors re-correction after publication promoting industry information sharing and improving editorial review processes could help to avoid the dissemination of misinformation in academic papers.