关系理论的概念与分类--迈农“观念性关系”与胡塞尔“心理性关系”的比较研究
Theory and Classification of Relations:Meinong’s Ideal Relations and Husserl’s Psychical Relations
摘要
关系理论是迈农和胡塞尔教职论文中的核心问题。迈农曾指出胡塞尔涉嫌抄袭。从表面上看,迈农的“观念性关系”和“实在性关系”的二分法,与胡塞尔的“心理性关系”和“物理性关系”的区分很相似;但究其实质,胡塞尔的“心理性关系”和迈农的“观念性关系”并不同,胡塞尔在这个论题上并未抄袭迈农。不过,胡塞尔早期的关系理论面临着与迈农类似的难题,即需要说明关系是如何建立的。对这个难题的回应,可能会迫使胡塞尔接受一种心理主义式的算术哲学观。
作者
龚艳
何浩平
GONG Yan;HE Hao-ping
出处
《南京大学学报（哲学．人文科学．社会科学）》
CSSCI
北大核心
2020年第4期93-101,共9页
Journal of Nanjing University(Philosophy,Humanities and Social Sciences)
基金
国家社会科学基金项目(15CZX039)。
二级参考文献8
-
1Frege, "Review of Dr. E. Husserl's Philosophy of Arithmetic", Mohanty, ed. , Readings on Edmund Husserl's Logical Investigations, Martinu Nijhoff, 1977, pp. 6 ~21.
-
2D. F~llesdal, "Husserl and Frege: A Contribution to Elucidating the Origins of Phenomenological Philosophy", L. Haaparanta, ed., Mind, Meaning and Mathematics: Essays on the Philosophical Views of Husserl and Frege, Synthese Library 237, Kluwer, 1994, pp. 3 ~50.
-
3skar Becker, "The Philosophy of Edmund Husserl", 1)2~ W. Biemel, "The Decisive Phases in the Development of Husserl's Phenomenology", The Phenomenology of Husserl. Selected Critical Readings, R. O. Elveton, trans, and ed. , Noesis Press, 1970, pp. 38 ~69, pp. 140 ~ 163.
-
4Husserl, Philosophy of Arithmetic: Psychological and Logical Investigations, D. Willard, trans., Kluwer, 2003, p. 13, p. 19, p. 21, p. 77, p. 84, p. 275, p. 258, p. 206, p. 206, p. 271, p. 273, p. 307.
-
5胡塞尔:《形式逻辑和先验逻辑——逻辑理性批评研究》,李幼蒸译,中国人民大学出版社,2012,第213—217页.第72—73页.
-
6J. P. Miller, Numbers in Absence and Presence, Nijhoff, 1982, p. 21.
-
7Husserl, "Letter from E. Husserl to Carl Stumpf", Early Writings in the Philosophy of Logic and Mathematics, D. Willard, trans., Kluwer, pp. 12 ~ 19, pp. 20-51.
-
8D. Willard, "Husserl On a Logic that Failed", Philosophical Review, 1, 1950, pp. 46 ~ 64~.
