欧美期刊同行评议模式发展趋势分析

Visual Analysis and Trend of Journal Peer Review Models in Europe and America

[目的/意义]旨在为国内学术期刊改进同行评议及国内同行评议理论研究提供参考。[方法/过程]以Richard-PaSCal-W ang[2017]同行评议模式分类模型精简版框架为分析工具,使用多维可视化方法,梳理欧美期刊13种同行评议模式,分析同行评议模式现状以及未来发展趋势。[结果/结论]欧美期刊同行评议模式呈现出参与度、透明度、自由度“三增加”的趋势。

[Purpose/significance]The paper is to provide references for domestic academic journals to improve peer review and domestic peer review theory research.[Method/process]The paper takes Richard-Pascal-Wang[2017]Peer Review Mode Classification Model Lite Model Framework as an analysis tool,uses multi-dimensional visualization methods to comb thirteen peer review models of European and American journals,and discusses the current status and future development trends of the peer review model.[Result/conclusion]The peer review model of European and American journals shows a trend of“three increases”in participation,transparency and freedom.