基于把关人理论谈高校学报的审稿流程

On the Review Process of University Journals Based on the Gatekeeper Theory

学报的整个审稿流程涉及多层把关,初审、复审、终审以及学术期刊特殊的同行专家评审。虽然整个流程有多个把关人,但由于学报特殊的体制因素,依然存在很多不足,从而影响整个把关的效果。为了保证学报把关人履行好自己的任务,在学报的审稿流程中,应该强化初审编辑的把关,在此基础上加强对专家审稿的约束,另外应该充分发挥编委会的作用,将编委会纳入把关环节,从而通过层层有效的把关保证学报的质量,促进学报的发展。

The review process of the academic journals in universities include many checkpoints,such as preliminary review,recheck,final review and the special review by experts.Although there are multiple gatekeepers throughout the review process,which still has many shortcomings due to the special institutional factors of the journal to affect the result.In order to ensure the academic gatekeepers fulfill their tasks,in the review process,we need to strengthen the work of preliminary review,and increase the constraints on the experts when they evaluate the papers.In addition to these measures,we need to make full use of the editorial board,so as to ensure the quality of the journal and promote the development.