我国刑事裁判文书说理研究

The Reasoning of Criminal Judgment Documents in China

刑事裁判文书的说理对提高其社会效果与法律效果具有重大意义。从刑事裁判文书说理的事实层级明晰刑事裁判文书说理“是什么”的问题、核心层级说明刑事裁判文书之因果逻辑、实践层级说明刑事裁判文书说理施行方法等三个层级,论证了刑事裁判文书说理的立足起点、把控关键与目标指向,为我国刑事裁判文书的撰写提供了理论借鉴和实践指导。

The reasoning of criminal judgment documents is of great significance to improve documents'social and legal effects.From the perspective of factual levels of the reasoning,“what the reasoning of criminal judgment documents is”has been interpreted;from the perspective of core level of reasoning,the causality and logic of documents have been explained;from the perspective of the practice level of the reasoning,the implementation methods of documents'three levels have been introduced.This paper demonstrates the starting points,key points and target orientation of the reasoning,providing theoretical references and practical guidance for the writing of criminal judgment documents in China.