浙江图书馆藏《三朝北盟会编》明清抄本考论

Textual Research on the Ming and Qing Manuscripts of Sanchaobeimenghuibian Collected in Zhejiang Library

浙江图书馆藏有三种《三朝北盟会编》抄本,其中明抄本为王鸣盛旧藏,敦诗书阁清抄本为上虞连氏父子旧藏,另一种清抄本为嘉业堂旧藏,而学界以为此抄本早已亡佚。论文介绍此三种抄本的基本情况,梳理其递藏源流,分析其相对于许涵度刻本的独特价值。并将此三种抄本互相对照,辨析其文字优劣,认为嘉业堂旧藏清抄本的质量为三种抄本中最佳。

There are three kinds of manuscripts of Sanchaobeimenghuibian in Zhejiang Library,among which the handwritten copy in Ming dynasty is the collection of Wang Mingsheng,the handwritten copy in Qing dynasty of Dunshishuge is the collection of Lian Zhongyu and his son,and the other handwritten copy in Qing dynasty is the collection of Jiaye Tang,which is thought to be lost by scholars.This paper introduces the basic situation of these three kinds of manuscripts,combs the source of their transfer and collection,and analyzes their unique value compared with Xu handu’s copy.By comparing the three manuscripts with each other and analyzing their characters,it is concluded that the quality of the handwritten copy in Qing dynasty collected by Jiayetang is the best of the three manuscripts.