北京市医学伦理审查互认现场督导检查评分标准的制订与初步应用

Formulation and preliminary application of on-site supervision and inspection scoring standards for mutual recognition of medical ethics review in Beijing

目的为检验伦理审查互认的实施效果,北京市卫生健康委员会决定对联盟中25家具备主审资质的医疗机构进行现场督导检查,为此联盟制定了伦理审查互认现场督导检查的评分标准,以保证检查的客观性和一致性。方法评分标准主要参考《北京市医学伦理审查互认联盟工作规则》及25家医疗机构前期基本调研情况制订。结果评分标准由3个一级指标、10个二级指标和13个三级指标构成。3个一级指标分别为制度建设(30分)、互认情况(25分)和审查效率(45分)。结论评分标准为北京市医学伦理审查互认推进的重要工具,尽管个别指标在现阶段有使用上的局限性,但总体能较全面地考察伦理审查互认的实施情况及效果,且有一定可操作性。

Objective In order to test the implementation effect of the mutual recognition of ethics,the Beijing Municipal Health Commission decided to conduct on-site supervision and inspection of the 25 medical institutions in the alliance that have the qualifications for the main review.To this end,the alliance has formulated the scoring standards for the on-site supervision and inspection of mutual recognition of ethical review to ensure the objectivity and consistency of the inspection.Methods The scoring standard is mainly formulated with reference to the Working Rules of Beijing Medical Ethics Review Mutual Recognition Alliance and the preliminary basic research of 25 medical institutions.Results The scoring standard consists of 3 first-level indicators,10 second-level indicators and 13 third-level indicators.The three first-level indicators are system construction(30 points),implementation of mutual recognition(25 points)and review efficiency(45 points).Conclusion The scoring standard is an important tool for promoting mutual recognition of medical ethics review in Beijing.Although individual indicators have limitations in their use at the current stage,in general,they can be used to comprehensively examine the implementation and effect of mutual recognition of ethical review,and have certain operability.