章太炎《春秋左传读》引钟鼎文字考论

A Textual Research on the Studyof The Quotation of Inscriptions on Bronze in Zhang Taiyan's Annotation of the Zuo Zhuan(Chunqiu ZuoZhuan Du)

一般认为,章太炎先生对出土文字材料持较为保守的态度。但通过考察我们发现,受时代氛围、学术师承的影响,太炎先生在早期的学术实践中对钟鼎文字进行了一定的引证和运用。我们即以章太炎的《春秋左传读》为研究对象,详尽考察其中钟鼎文字的材料来源及所发挥作用,并尝试对其运用得失进行评价。此外,我们通过太炎先生其他学术著作中的相关材料、论述,还能够看到其前后部分材料观点上的延续性,以及推测他对钟鼎文字等出土材料态度发生转变的原因。

it is generally believed that Mr.Zhang Taiyan holds a relatively conservative attitude towards the unearthed written materials.However,through investigation,we will find that under the influence of the atmosphere of the times and academic succession,Mr.Taiyan cited and applied the Inscriptions on Bronze in his early academic practice.We take Zhang Taiyan's Annotation of the Zuo Zhuan(Chunqiu ZuoZhuan Du),as the research object,investigate in detail the material sources and functions of bronzeware characters,and try to evaluate the gains and losses of its application.In addition,through the relevant materials and discussions in Mr.Taiyan's other academic works,we can also see the continuity of his views on some materials before and after him,and speculate the reasons for his change in his attitude towards written materials such as Inscriptions on Bronze.