客观违法性论向二元违法性论之发展

From Objective Illegitimacy to Dual Illegitimacy

在对传统客观违法性论质疑的基础上,产生了修正客观违法性论。修正客观违法性论认为违法的“客观性”并不在于违法评价对象的客观性,而是在于评价“标准”的客观性。修正客观违法性论实质上部分认可了主观违法要素,违法性评价应当同时考虑行为的主观面和客观面。修正客观违法性论在“客观标准”掩盖下,整合客观违法要素和主观违法要素,实现了对传统客观违法性论的超越和飞跃,修正客观违法性论成为传统客观违法性论向二元违法性论过渡的桥梁。

Calling in question the traditional objective illegitimacy gives rise to the idea of objective illegitimacy revision,which holds that the objectivity of illegitimacy is not the objectivity of the evaluation object but the objectivity of evaluation criteria.In essence the idea of objective illegitimacy revision partly acknowledges subjective illegitimacy,and considers both the subjective and objective aspects of the illegitimacy in evaluation.Objective illegitimacy revision integrates the subjective and objective elements,transcends traditional objective illegitimacy,and facilitates the transformation from traditional objective illegitimacy to dual illegitimacy.