弱化的论域:“风格”——评陈海燕《中国木偶戏地域性风格分析与研究》

Weakened Theory Domain:Style——a Review of Analysis and Research on Regional Style of Chinese Puppet Shows by Chen Haiyan

《中国木偶戏地域性风格分析与研究》作为我国第一部积极关注中国多地域木偶戏风格的论著,为构建中国木偶戏风格论作了初步探索,成为木偶戏研究中重要的基础性研究资料。但该著对“风格”的内涵与外延遗漏阐释,对各地木偶戏典型艺术风格延留式、浅隐式、无影式的隐性阐述方式,对各地木偶戏艺术风格的生成机制以及“同中之异”和“异中之同”等现象蜻蜓点水式的剖析,遮蔽了该著应有的光彩。

As the first book in China that actively pays attention to the style of China’s multi regional puppet show,Analysis and Research on the Regional Style of Chinese Puppet Shows has made a preliminary exploration for the construction of the style theory of Chinese puppet show,and has become an important basic research material in the study of puppet show.However,the book missed the interpretation of the connotation and extension of“style”,the implicit interpretation of the typical artistic style of puppet shows in various places,the generation mechanism of the artistic style of puppet shows in various places,and the analysis of the phenomenon of“differences in the same”and“similarities in the different”.