中国国家图书馆藏张祥云《鞠园藏书目》献疑

A Textual Research of Zhang Xiangyun’s Juyuan Bibliography in National Library of China

张祥云是清乾嘉时期福建藏书大家,然其声名、藏书湮没无闻。郑振铎《西谛书目》始收“张祥云藏”《鞠园藏书目》,此目今存中国国家图书馆,题作“张祥云编”。然通考全目,可以发现此目收录不少张氏去世后的书籍,而明确可知经过张氏收藏的书籍不见于此目,加之书目体例不一,错讹较多,故《鞠园藏书目》题作张祥云藏或编值得商榷。

Zhang Xiangyun was a famous Fujian bibliophile in the period of Qianlong and Jiaqing in Qing Dynasty,but he was not well known.For the first time,Zheng zhenduo’s Xidi Bibliography includes“Zhang Xiangyun’s collection”Juyuan Bibliography.This book complicated by Zhang Xiangyun is kept in National Library of China.Through this book,we can find that it included quiet a few books that compliated after Zhang’s died,and it didn’t included some once he collected.Also,the compiling style was not unified,and it had some errors and poor quality.Therefore,this Juyuan Bibliography is questionable.