繁简适度范导下间接证据裁判如何说理?--以法发[2018]10号第6条为中心

How to Justify the Adjudicative Instruments with Indirect Evidence in the Background of Diversion of Complexity and Simplicity:Centered on the Article 6 of the Opinions on Strengthening and Standardizing the Analysis and Reasoning in Adjudicative Instruments

《最高人民法院关于加强和规范裁判文书释法说理的指导意见》规定繁简适度的说理原则。依据间接证据认定事实的裁判相比于依据直接证据认定事实的裁判而言更需强化说理。本文立足于方法论,总结归纳间接证据裁判说理的六条“一阶规则”和四条“二阶规则”,意图为间接证据裁判说理提供指引。