广州黄埔5号线有轨电车与智轨制式比选分析

Comparative analysis on tram and smart rail system in Huangpu line No.5 in Guangzhou City

中低运量轨道交通中有轨电车和智轨两种制式有很多类似之处,各自都有自身的优缺点,很多城市在中低运量轨道交通规划时都曾纠结选择哪种制式。以广州市黄埔区有轨电车5号线一期工程有轨电车与智轨制式比选为例,分析两种制式对5号线的适应性,从车辆参数、运量、项目建设审批难度、工期、路权、工程量、成本、环保、适应性、舒适性、旅行时间、可靠性等方面进行充分比选确定推荐方案,也可为其他城市中低运量轨道交通系统选型提供一定的参考。

There are many similarities between the tram and smart rail systems for low and medium capacity rail transport,and each has its own advantages and disadvantages.Therefore,many cities have struggled with which system to choose when planning for low and medium capacity rail transport.Taking the comparative selection between tram and smart rail system for the first phase of Guangzhou Huangpu tram line No.5 project as an example,the thesis analyzes the adaptability of the above-mentioned two systems to line No.5,and determines the recommended solution through full comparison in terms of vehicle parameters,capacity,project construction approval difficulty,construction period,right of way,engineering volume,cost,environmental protection,adaptability,comfort,travel time and reliability,etc.,which can also provide some reference for the selection of low and medium capacity rail transport systems in other cities.