我国高校医学学报参考文献质量分析——兼对《山西医科大学学报》发展的思考

Quality analysis of references of medical journals in Chinese colleges and universities:reflections on the development of Journal of Shanxi Medical University

目的本文基于参考文献的特征指标及计量学指标,试图分析学术期刊参考文献的质量对学术期刊质量的影响。方法按照综合评价总分高低选取评分前5、中5和后5共15种中国医药大学学报作为样本并将其分为3组。对15种期刊2020年第1期所有文章的参考文献本身及参考文献对应的中文来源期刊的核心影响因子、核心总被引频次、综合评价总分等计量学指标进行统计,运用统计学的方法分析3组期刊指标之间的差异性。结果参考文献的外文占比,篇均引文数以及来源期刊的核心总被引频次、核心权威因子、基金论文比和综合评价总分在组间的差异有统计学意义。结论上述6项指标在期刊质量评价方面有积极作用,为从参考文献质量方面评价期刊质量提供一种新的视角,为期刊评价和来稿的选择提供新的视角。

Objective To analyze the influence of the quality of references on the quality of academic journals based on the characte-ristic indexes and metrological indexes of the references.Methods The top 5,middle 5 and bottom 5 journals were selected according to the total score of comprehensive evaluation,and the 15 journals of Chinese medical universities were divided into three groups.The metrological indicators such as core impact factor,core total citation frequency and total score of comprehensive evaluation of the refe-rences and their source journals were counted,and the differences between groups were analyzed by statistical analysis method.Results There were statistically significant differences in the proportion of foreign languages in the references,the average number of citations in each article,the core cited frequency,the core authority factor,the ratio of funded papers and the total score of comprehensive evaluation of the source journals.Conclusion The results suggest that the above six indexes have positive effects on the quality evaluation of periodicals,which provides a new perspective for evaluating the quality of periodicals from the quality of references,and provides a new perspective for the evaluation of periodicals and the selection of manuscripts.