论裁判理由的上诉利益

On the Appeal Interest of the Grounds of Referee

我国裁判理由中法院认定的事实可以产生预决效力。根据《中华人民共和国民事诉讼法》及相关司法解释的规定,裁判理由的预决效力在层次上可以分为绝对的预决效力、相对的预决效力和较弱的预决效力。预决效力的强弱对上诉利益判断有着直接的影响。具体而言,当事人对与本案有关事实不服的上诉利益的判断应区分该事实所能产生的效力:若该事实能够产生绝对的预决效力或者相对的预决效力,当事人不服的应认可其上诉利益;若该事实仅能产生较弱的预决效力或者不产生预决效力,当事人不服的应否定其上诉利益。

The facts in the grounds of referee have the effect of pre-determination.The effect of pre-determination can be divided into absolute pre-decision effect,relative pre-decision effect and weak pre-decision effect,According to the Civil Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China and relevant judicial interpretation.The strength of the effect of pre-determination effect has a direct impact on the judgment of the appeal interests.The appeal interest of the parties dissatisfied with the facts related to the case should distinguish the effect of the fact.If the fact will produce absolute or relative pre-determination effects,the appeal interest should be recognized;if the fact has only a weak pre-decision effect or does not produce a pre-decision effect,the appeal interest should be denied.