双面真理论与黑格尔辩证法的关系研究

On the Relationship Between Dialetheism and Hegel s Dialectics

在一定范围内承认“真矛盾”的“双面真理论”,是普利斯特等人构建亚相容逻辑的思想基础,而普利斯特把黑格尔的辩证法作为其双面真理论的重要思想来源之一,并就此做了多方论证。然而,菲卡拉等人对普利斯特的论证进行了系统性批判,并就黑格尔矛盾辩证法与双面真理论的关系提出了建设性思考。深入考察这样的研究成果,有助于进一步厘清逻辑矛盾、辩证矛盾与逻辑悖论的关系,从而正确理解形式逻辑与辩证思维方法论的关系。

“Dialetheism”,which recognizes“true contradictions”in a certain scope,is the ideological basis for Priest,et al to construct paraconsistent logics,and Priest regards Hegel s dialectics as one of the important ideological sources of his dialetheism,and has made many arguments for it.However,Ficara,et al have made a systematic criticism of Priest s arguments and put forward a series of constructive thoughts on the relationship between Hegel s dialectics of contradictions and dialetheism.An in-depth study of such research results will help us to further clarify the relationship among logical contradictions,dialectical contradictions and logical paradoxes,so as to correctly understand the relationship between the formal logic and the dialectical thinking methodology.