期刊跨学科性对期刊评价的影响

Influence of journal interdisciplinarity on journal evaluation

【目的】梳理并综述期刊跨学科性测度及期刊跨学科性对期刊评价影响研究的发展态势,总结期刊跨学科研究的内容和进展。【方法】利用Web of Science核心合集和CNKI数据库检索期刊跨学科性和期刊评价的相关文献,通过筛选和分析重要文献,对期刊跨学科性及其对期刊排名或期刊评价指标的影响进行系统综述和述评。【结果】在不同学科领域,期刊跨学科性对期刊评价或期刊排名的影响是不同的:有的学科领域的跨学科期刊在期刊排名中占据优势,而有的学科领域的跨学科期刊在期刊排名中处于劣势,在有的学科领域中期刊跨学科性对期刊排名没有明显的影响。【结论】在评价跨学科期刊或利用期刊排名进行学术评价时,要注意根据不同学科领域的实际情况来采取相应的措施。

[Purposes]This article aims to summarize the development trend of research on measuring journal interdisciplinarity and the influence of journal interdisciplinarity on journal evaluation.It provides an overview of research content and progress in journal interdisciplinarity.[Methods]By using the core database of Web of Science and CNKI database to search the literature related to the interdisciplinarity and evaluation of journals,as well as screening and analyzing the important literature,the journal interdisciplinarity and its influence on journal rankings or journal evaluation indexes were systematically reviewed.[Findings]The influence of journal interdisciplinarity on journal evaluation or journal rankings varies across different disciplines,with interdisciplinary journals having an advantage in journal rankings in some disciplines.In contrast,other interdisciplinary journals are at a disadvantage in journal rankings,and in some disciplines,journal interdisciplinarity has no significant influence on journal rankings.[Conclusions]When evaluating interdisciplinary journals or using journal rankings for academic evaluation,researchers should take corresponding measures based on the actual situation in different disciplines.