读《艺术叛徒:刘海粟的艺术策略与身份认同》之思

On Reading Traitor to Art:Artistic Strategy and Identity of Liu Haisu

宋金明《艺术叛徒:刘海粟的艺术策略与身份认同》一文从多角度辨析了刘海粟的声名构建过程,通过诸多谋划与策略,最终构筑自己的身份认同。然与笔者所知史实有所相悖,故提出若干疑问与之商榷,通过钩稽宋文的逻辑偏差与文献疏漏等问题,进行辨析与揭橥。

The article Traitor to Art:Artistic Strategy and Identity of Liu Haisu by Song Jinming analyzes from multiple aspects how Liu Haisu built his reputation,who finally built his identity through many plans and strategies.However,because this article is inconsistent with historical facts that I know,I raise some questions for discussion in this paper from eight perspectives by examining the deviation of logic and the omission of documents in Song's article.