论文出版前撤稿的原因与对策分析——以《湖南工业大学学报》59篇撤稿论文为例

Analysis of the Reasons and Countermeasures for the Withdrawal of Papers Before Publication:A Case Study of 59 Retracted Papers in the Journal of Hunan University of Technology

为了探讨论文出版前撤稿的原因与应对策略,通过逐篇查阅《湖南工业大学学报》(简称学报)办刊系统中已退稿件,用Excel统计得出2018—2023年(截至2023-10-26),学报出版前撤稿的文章,共59篇。并通过查阅中国知网数据库、比对投稿系统中的未发表相似文献、打电话或发邮件回访作者等方式,多角度分析了作者撤稿的原因。作者“一稿多投”,稿件问题多而作者修改不到位,出版周期太长,刊期不能满足作者毕业、评职称要求等是造成论文出版前撤稿的主要原因。因此,编辑出版单位应尽量遏制“一稿多投”现象,并规范稿件处理流程以缩短审稿周期,利用网络优先出版以缩短发文时滞。

In view of an inquiry into the reasons and countermeasures for the withdrawal of papers before publication,by using Excel,a statistical analysis has been made of a total of 59 articles that had been withdrawn from the publication system of the Journal of Hunan University of Technology(referred to as the Journal)from 2018 to 2023(as of October 26,2023),followed by a further analysis of the reasons for authors’withdrawal from multiple perspectives by consulting the CNKI database,comparing similar unpublished literature in the submission system,and making phone calls or email follow-up to the author.The main reasons for the withdrawal of papers before publication include author’s“multiple submissions of the same manuscript”,insufficient revision of manuscripts with numerousflaws,long publication cycles,and inability to meet the author’s graduation and professional title evaluation requirements,etc.Therefore,editorial and publishing units should try to resolutely eradicate“multiple submissions of the same manuscript”,standardize the manuscript processing process so as to shorten the review cycle,and give priority to online publication,thus shortening the publication delay.