关于《营造法式》研究若干议题的读书笔记

Some Notes on the Studies in Yingzao fashi

作为一篇史学史读书笔记,本文试从《营造法式》研究诸多议题之中选择四个争议较大且持续较久者,通过比较阅读揭示学者的自我反思和修正,不同学者之间观点的争鸣和砥砺,以及他们之间的继承与发展。这四个议题是:1.“以材为祖”如何应用?2.《营造法式》是否规定了建筑的一切尺度都受材份制约?3.“材分八等”的依据何在?4.《营造法式》的编纂是否受到了南方建筑的影响?

This historiographical essay is a collection of reading notes that outlines the debates and developments in the study of Song dynasty state building standards in the Yingzhao Fashi.A comparative reading of scholarly works highlights four key issues:i)how the standard module(cai)prescribed in the book was applied in building construction,ii)whether all measurements in a building’s construction were subject to cai,iii)the logic behind the division of the eight cai grades,and iv)whether the compilation of these state standards was influenced by contemporary architecture in Southern China.