行政举报人原告资格的司法审查困境与出路——以33份判决为例

The Dilemma of Judicial Review of Plaintiff Qualification in Administrative Reporting and Countermeasures-Based on 33 Judicial Judgments

通过梳理司法审判中的典型案例,审视案例背后的裁判逻辑,针对“保护规范理论”本土化适用的问题以及司法审查所存在的不足,从完善“利害关系”标准的角度出发,并结合具体的行政实体权利行使,在保护规范理论对举报人原告资格认定的冲击、我国行政诉讼中原告资格判断标准的完善两方面对举报人原告资格认定标准路径进行改进。

Typical cases in the justice are sorted out,and the judgment logic is examined.The localized application of protection norm theory and insufficient judicial review are studied.The identification standard of the plaintiff qualification is improved through refining the standard of interest,reducing the impact of the protection norm theory on the plaintiff qualification identification,and revising the standard of plaintiff qualification in administrative actions combining the exercise of specific administrative entity rights.