Uncertainties of critical temperatures based on higher-order fluctuations of the largest fragment charge

The new signature of liquid-gas phase transition has been well indicated by the higher-order fluctuations of the largest fragment charge,but the uncertainties of critical temperatures based on this signature have not been revealed.This study extracts the critical temperatures of liquid-gas phase transition in nuclear reactions and investigates their uncertainties.Utilizing the isospin-dependent quantum molecular dynamics model in conjunction with the statistical model GEMINI enables us to describe the dynamical path from the initial to the final state.An isotope thermometer and a quantum fluctuation thermometer are employed to extract the nuclear temperature.The higher-order fluctuations of the largest fragment charge and critical temperatures are studied in^(124)Sn+^(120)Sn collisions ranging from 400 to 1000 MeV/nucleon and^(124)Sn+AZ collisions at 600 MeV/nucleon.Observations revealed that the pseudo-critical point is robustly indicated by the higher-order fluctuations of the largest fragment charge.The critical temperatures extracted by the isotope thermometer are relatively consistent,with an uncertainty of 15%,while those obtained by the quantum fluctuation thermometer are heavily influenced by the incident energy and mass number of target nuclei.The excitation energy E∗and bound charge Zbound are used for event-sorting.These two ensembles represent the statistical properties of the initial and final states of the system,respectively.The initial-final correlations of statistical properties might lead to two phenomena.First,the size distribution of the largest fragment at the pseudo-critical point based on the Zbound ensemble is wide,while that based on E∗ensemble exhibits bimodality,which is a typical characteristic in the liquid-gas coexistence of a finite system.Second,the temperature at the pseudo-critical point based on the Zbound ensemble is higher than that based on the E∗ensemble.Furthermore,the projectile-like system exhibits a significant dynamical effect in its evolution path from the initial to final state,closely associated with the fluctuation of critical temperature.