摘要
通过对2012-2021年全国43例医疗事故罪相关判决书的分析,我们掌握了现阶段我国医疗事故罪的发案和定罪量刑情况。在司法实践中,我们发现医疗事故罪仍存在“严重不负责任”的确认标准欠明、“严重损害就诊人身体健康”的认定与医学原理部分相斥、被害人特殊体质介入型案件的因果关系判断方法有误以及职业禁止处分的适用遭遇悬搁等问题,并针对这些问题提出完善医疗事故罪司法实践的建议。
Based on the relevant judgments of 43 cases of medical malpractice crimes,we analyzed the occurrence,conviction and sentencing of medical malpractice crimes in our country at this stage,and found that there is still“serious irresponsibility”in the judicial practice of medical malpractice crimes.The standard of confirmation is not clear,the identification of“serious harm to the physical health of the patient”is partially repugnant to the principles of medicine,and there are methodological errors in the judgment of the causal relationship of interventional cases with the victim’s special physique,and the application of occupational prohibitions has encountered outstanding problems,and tried to put forward suggestions for the improvement of the judicial practice of medical malpractice crimes.
作者
曹兴华
吕婉婧
Cao Xinghua;lv Wanjing(School of Law,Beijing University of Chinese Medicine,Beijing 100029,China;School of Intellectual Property Research,Xiamen University,Xiamen 361005,China)
出处
《锦州医科大学学报（社会科学版）》
2024年第1期23-29,35,共8页
Journal of Jinzhou Medical University(Social Science Edition)
基金
四川医事卫生法治研究中心立项项目“医疗事故罪因果关系判断实证研究”(编号:YF21-Q04)
2021年度四川省社区矫正研究中心资助项目“社区矫正法实施后地方社区矫正实施细则研究”(编号:SQJZ2021-04)
中央高校基本科研业务费专项资金资助项目“刑事一体化视域下新矫治刑罚理论的逻辑机理与实践路径研究”(编号:2023-JYB-PY-003)的研究成果。
关键词
医疗事故罪
司法实践
因果关系
特殊体质
medical malpractice crime
judicial practice
causality
special physique
